Home About Forum Founder Members Registration Online Contact Us Query
 
Dalit 
  Minorities
 
 
Dalit
  Muslims
  Budhism
  International Situation
  Media
  Nepal
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
The Dalit and Minorities International Conference held in New Delhi on 27-28 December 2006 on the theme of Power to the Powerless, had serious deliberations on the issue of backwardness of minorities especially Muslims who have been identified socially, educationally and economically backward class of citizens by various panels including the Gopal Singh Committee (1983) and the Sachchar Committee (2006). The participants stressed that the Indian Constitution provides for almost all relevant rights to minorities in cultural, religious and linguistic spheres. But such rights have not been secured by minorities especially Muslim community mainly due to their socio-economic and educational backwardness.

The factor of backwardness has cumulative and circular effects on the overall development of the community as well as the whole country. It was also noted that minorities especially the Muslims have some major grievances against many incidents of inactions and discriminations in the case of communal riots. Participants were unanimous in their views on the lack of educational facilities and other infrastructures like adequate water supply, electricity, sanitation, health centres, community centres, etc. in those areas/localities where Muslims constitute substantial percentage of population. The participants appreciated recent declarations of the Prime Minister, the Ministry of Minority Affairs, the Ministry of Human Resource Development, the Indian National Congress, the Lok Janshakti Party, and the other surveys for addressing the issue of backwardness and discrimination. The two-day international meet made the following resolutions:
 
1.
The conference had wide-ranging and in-depth discussions on the present socio-economic and cultural status of the Muslims of India. It was recognized that the community as a whole has undergone patent and conspicuous decline in all spheres that define the well being of any community. The conference expressed grave concern at the inadequate attention that the problems of Indian Muslims have so far received from the Indian state which does not augur well for the peace, prosperity and cohesion of the nation as a whole. It was unanimously recognized that immediate steps need to be taken to arrest any further deterioration in its status by addressing the problems of the community as a whole and not by compartmentalizing it into artificial segments.
   
2.
The system of reservation in employment and access to institutions of education and training has proved invaluable in reducing disparities in an essentially unequal and socially stratified society. While much more remains to be done in this sphere including access to employment in productive sectors outside the government which play an ever increasing role in the economy, a time has come when the issue of backwardness of Muslims must be addressed through the time tested machinery of reservations.
The conference noted that the bulk of the Muslim population belongs to castes which have been identified to be the socially and educationally backward classes and on that basis included in the list of socially and educationally backward classes. They are thus eligible for reservation of 27 per cent. They are getting some benefits of reservation thereby but not commensurate their proportion among the backward classes.. Measures like categorization of backward classes and distribution of 27 per cent among different categories of sub-categories of backward classes need to be introduced.
   
3.
The constitution of the country extends a valuable right to the religious and linguistic minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. The actual benefits of this right have been uneven across the state, and in the absence of a legislative framework on the subject, it has not been possible for the central government to effectively safeguard these rights and to provide for maintenance of institutions of educationally backward minorities like the Indian Muslims. It was also appreciated that in the peculiar circumstances prevailing in the country the educational needs of religious and linguistic minorities may not be identical.

The conference, accordingly, resolved to call upon the central government to immediately bring forward a legislation giving effect to the letter and spirit of Article-30(1) of the constitution of India. Such legislation must have an enabling provision for direct central assistance, recurring and non recurring, to institutions established by educationally very backward religious minorities. The conference also calls upon the central government to also consider suitably amending the constitution of India if it appears necessary that the differing educational needs of religious and linguistic minorities need to be properly differentiated.
   
4.
The conference notes with concern that years of constant endeavour and struggles of Indian Muslims for restoration of the minority character of the Aligarh Muslim University which resulted in the amendments in the Aligarh Muslim University Act 1981, have been put in serious jeopardy by a recent pronouncement of the Allahabad High Court that the Parliament did not have the power to undo the effects of an earlier judgment of the Supreme Court which had denied the minority status of the University. It was also noted that some of the existing arrangements for managing the affairs of the University are not conducive to efficient academic and executive management.
The conference demands that suitable legislative measures, including if necessary constitutional amendment, be immediately undertaken to remove all doubts about the availability of all rights under Article-30(1) of the constitution to the Aligarh Muslim University. Such amendments must in particular ensure that the University is in a position to provide for adequate representation to Indian Muslims for receiving education in the University. Necessary amendments to the charter of the institution to make it a more efficient instrument of achieving its objectives be also considered.
   
5.
Urdu language, besides being a symbol of the synthetic culture of the country is an important ‘marker’ of the cultural identity of large sections of Indian Muslims. The facilities made available for preservation and promotion of this language and for imparting education through the medium of this language as indeed teaching of the language itself have been woefully inadequate. The conference recognizes that the problems faced by the language in the country are complex and vary in different parts. Considering that in a situation of linguistically distinct states, Urdu does not have an ‘area’ of its own it is clear that the central government must assume specific responsibility with reference to this language.
The conference, therefore, strongly recommends that a “National Policy on Urdu” be formulated without delay. The policy must address the region specific requirements to preserve and promote the language in educational and other spheres.
   
6.
Special Bill pertaining to prevention and control of communal violence which has been pending in Parliament should immediately be passed. The Central and State Governments should ensure equal protection of laws and their unbiased implementation to all citizens including accountability on the District Administration particularly District Magistrates and senior police officials. As the police is well known to have played partisan role in implicating innocent Muslims and freeing the culprits belonging to other communities in major communal riots, genocide and obnoxious incidences in the country such as Mumbai, Gujarat, Nanded, Malegaon, Bhiwandi, Bhagalpur, Hashimpura, Maliyana etc. The Central Government therefore should direct the Intelligence Bureau/ Central Bureau of Investigation to investigate/ enquire such intentional negligence and hobnobbing with the culprits committed by these officials and suggest appropriate measures for the said application including their punishment.
   
7.
Fast Track Courts should be established for trying all crimes committed during communal riots in order to cultivate the confidence of the victims in established justice system. The compensation for victims of communal riots is inadequate. The Government was realistic in arriving at quantum of compensation for the victims of 1984 riots. The same standard of compensation should be applied to all subsequent communal riots retrospectively and for the victims of any future communal riots. Child-victims and children of victims of communal riots should be given the best education in good government institutions at government’s cost. Women widowed as a result of communal riots should be given jobs in accordance with their qualification and also should be rehabilitated so that they are able to maintain themselves and their children and their education satisfactorily. People who are victims of communal riots and who are permanently or long-term disabled should be helped to find appropriate means of livelihood including jobs if qualified on priority basis under the quota for physically disabled. In the same manner any other category of victims of communal riots and terrorist acts should be given full rehabilitation appropriately.
   
8. A disproportionately large number of under-trial inmates of jail are members of backward classes of Muslims, Dalits, Backward Classes and also other poor. This shows lopsidedness of police investigation whereby the most vulnerable are picked up whenever any crime takes place. This needs to be corrected. It also shows that a large chunk of our population particularly poor Muslims are victims of unemployment on account of which they tend to be misguided. This needs to be taken note of and corrective steps for rapid employment generation for such categories including poor Muslims should be undertaken by the State and private industrial sector.
   
9. An atmosphere should be created by the Government of India and the civil society of India within the country and by Indian initiative internationally to counteract the widespread tendency to dub the entire Muslim community as terrorists or lawless, and on account of a few misguided individuals who indulge in such acts and who happen to be Muslims. The intolerance towards a cultural identity factor prevalent with its rich background of pluralism and tolerance is an eminent position to take initiative in this regard internationally.
   
10. The rapid growth of private TV channels and other media, that sometimes represent the views of limited classes, is an unfortunate reality. Since 1990 the growth of private TV channels is in direct proportion to the rising communal temperature. Therefore to curb the socially-biased media it is an absolute imperative that the State takes the lead to establish an independent TV channel, and it should be accelerated.
   
11. The National Commission for Minorities should immediately be given constitutional status with adequate rights and powers.
   
12. A permanent statutory body should be created for collecting socio-economic data pertaining to Indian Muslims.
   
13. A permanent body should be created for monitoring and providing legal assistance in matters pertaining to criminal justice, equity and equality before law.
   
14. District Magistrates should be held accountable for preparing data banks of Muslims’ social, educational and economic status every three years.
   
15. Reports of all major enquiry commissions pertaining to major communal riots should be analyzed and their recommendations which are still relevant should be implemented.
   
16. A permanent body should be established for providing micro credit on easy terms to weaker sections of Muslims for generating self-employment.
   
17. Establishment of permanent national and state commissions for promoting primary, secondary and higher level education for Muslim youth.
   
18. The backward community should have proportionate share in every governmental scheme at all levels.
   
19. Muslims should be given adequate and fair share in public employment in the larger interests of the country.
   
20. There should be composite posting in those police stations and district administration where Muslims constitute substantial population.
 
Developed by: Aj Infotek